Nutrition Outlook

with Annette Maggi, Registered Dietitian

Perfect is the Enemy of Good

On Friday, I sat through a round of presentations at the Institute of Medicine’s Committee Meeting on Front of Packaging Labeling Systems.  In layman’s terms, the committee is trying to decide the best method for highlighting “healthy”  or “better for you” foods on the front of the food packages so consumers don’t have to study the in-depth information on the Nutrition Facts Panel.

The committee’s job is due diligence, and I get that.  We want our government and policy organizations to be researching, investigating and exploring all the options.  But at some point, from my perspective, the discussion and debate becomes exhausting.  I’m a dietitian, I truly care about these issues, but the ability of my colleagues to poke holes in and debate the various systems, and the advantages and disadvantages becomes exhausting.

And at this point, I call to mind a saying that many have said.  Perfect is the enemy of good.  While he didn’t coin the phrase, Dr. David Katz, the inventor of the NuVal scoring system I work with, will often bring it to mind when the debate gets too far into the minutia, too far into the details, too far into the weeds.

If what we want is a perfect solution, we’ll never get there.  If what we want is a really good system that can help consumers make more nutritious food decisions, we’re there.

Visit www.nuval.com to meet Dr. David Katz and to explore a really good, but perhaps not perfect, system.

April 10, 2010 | Categories Uncategorized | 1 Comment »

1 Comment »

  1. Comment by Dr. David L. Katz | April 10, 2010 @ 12:17 pm

    Thanks for this post, Annette.

    If I may chime in, there are very good reasons why nutrition guidance can never be ‘perfect.’ Even if we had truly ‘perfect’ nutrition facts for, say, a given box of cereal, it’s just plain silly to think that every box of the same cereal would be truly identical. Contents vary, and even the contents of contents vary- the nutritional composition of wheat grow in different places, in different climates, in differing soils…varies. So nutrition facts approximate the truth. Not perfect, but certainly good enough.

    If I may say so, NuVal is not just good; it is truly excellent. Can I justify this bold statement? Yes! As you know, we have data from a Harvard study- soon to be published- showing that, in 110,000 men and women- NuVal scores of the foods they ate were a BETTER predictor of their total chronic disease risk and all-cause mortality risk than the very best measures of overall diet quality available on the planet. That truly is better than good.

    Perfect- elusive, and generally impossible- can truly turn into the enemy of good when it causes interminable delay and failure to apply the knowledge and resources at our disposal. Were its fruitless pursuit to interfere with the widespread availability of NuVal to consumers, it would be the enemy of ‘excellent’ as well!

    As for the status quo- the combination of nutrient details most people don’t understand and virtually no one can sum up into a clear expression of overall nutritional quality, plus marketing messages by manufacturers that accentuate the positive and obscure all the rest- it’s just…bad. And until we use what we have, the status quo is what we get.


Post Comment

RSS Feed Comments