Nutrition Outlook

with Annette Maggi, Registered Dietitian

Is “One a Day” truth or fiction?

I know what I’m about to say is controversial.  But it’s the truth, and it’s a topic that bears discussion.

When I was pregnant, I didn’t take prenatal vitamins.  Every month when I went in for check-ups, the nurse yelled at me.  But let me clarify.  I didn’t take the standard, fully loaded prenatal vitamin.  But I did take a pill form of those nutrients I didn’t get enough of from food that are so important during pregnancy – folic acid, calcium, iron.

As a pregnant dietitian, I felt like I was eating a good variety of the right foods so didn’t need to take a fully loaded pill.  Today, I take omega-3 supplements and sporadically, lutein supplements.  I do not give my son Jack vitamins at all.  But some of my colleagues will contend that it’s not possible to get all the nutrients we need at the right levels by eating food.  There we have it – the great debate on supplements or no supplements.

In my mind, it’s worth the old college try to get all that you need from food.  Why?  Because food has many as-of-yet undefined nutrients that our bodies need.  I think, too, that some of us take a daily vitamin as a license to make less healthy food choices, figuring we’re getting what we need in the pill form.

I’m not suggesting that pregnant women avoid taking prenatal vitamins (always follow your doctor’s advice!).  I’m just saying that the goal should be getting all the nutrients we need by eating a variety of foods from all food groups.

Voice your opinion – for or against supplements?

Visit www.nuval.com to experience a system that gives credit to the vitamins and minerals in food.

July 27, 2010 | Categories Uncategorized | 5 Comments »

5 Comments »

  1. Comment by Jessica Levinson | July 28, 2010 @ 1:57 am

    I agree that as many nutrients as possible should come from food, and I too am a RD who doesn’t take a multi. I take what I know I need more of (vitamin D, calcium, omega-3s and folic acid) but nothing more. Glad to know I’m not alone!


  2. Comment by Kati Mora | July 28, 2010 @ 11:31 am

    When I was pregnant (both times!) neither of my OBs ever talked about nutrition with me. I am not sure if this was because they knew my background or if this was common practice. Nevertheless, unless a pregnant woman really understands nutrition and knows what she is doing, taking a prenatal is super important. I would rather be safe than sorry in this instance; however, I do agree that emphasizing nutrients from food and providing nutrition education to pregnant and non-pregnant individuals a like is key for optimal outcomes. :)

    Annette, I also wanted to say “thank you” for stopping by my blog! Let me know if you ever want to guest blog sometime about the NuVal system!

    ~Kati


  3. Comment by Alison H | July 30, 2010 @ 1:53 pm

    I find supplements hard to figure out. I have always been loyal to calcium supplements- but yesterday a study came out saying they do more harm than good, and may cause heart attacks. Hmmm….
    http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2010/07/30/128871128/calcium-supplements-may-increase-heart-attack-risk


  4. Comment by Sharon | August 2, 2010 @ 9:58 am

    I don’t take multi either. Omega-3s and vitamin D is all I take. Have never taken a multi although did take prenatal when I was pregnant (40 years ago) because I was not a dietitian then and really didn’t know anything about nutrition. I agree that supplementation with multi for everyone is over recommended. Real food is the way to go. I do wonder, however, that now that I’m older (66) and digestion and absorption are probably somewhat compromised by aging, if I might benefit from a “pill” although my guess is that absorption of individual nutrients from pill would also be compromised.


  5. Comment by Chef Laura Whalen | August 9, 2010 @ 6:58 pm

    I do take a vitamin a day and did take my pre-natal vitamins while pregnant with my son. But I thought it interesting that I was just talking today to a (younger) friend who is the mother of 3 and she explained to me that she took her 12-year old daughter off of vitamins because her daughter kept saying that she could eat cookies for lunch if she took her vitamin. I would like to think that everyone is getting the nutrients that they need from their food…but I have access to alot of family refrigerators, freezers and pantrys and I’m also at the grocery store nearly every day shopping for clients. It is no small wonder that our collective health is so poor in the US. I’m very happy to hear that NuVal is coming into the mainstream, many shoppers are confused about nutrition. Thanks for the great blog!


Post Comment

RSS Feed Comments